If you're looking to boost your productivity on macOS, automation tools are your best friends. Three titans dominate the landscape: BetterTouchTool, Keyboard Maestro, and Karabiner-Elements. Each offers unique strengths, but choosing the right one depends on your specific needs. Let's break them down.
Quick Overview
Before we dive deep, here's a quick look at each app's core strength:
- BetterTouchTool (BTT): The undisputed king of customizing input devices like trackpads, mice, keyboards, and the Touch Bar.
- Keyboard Maestro (KM): A powerhouse for creating complex macros and automating workflows across applications.
- Karabiner-Elements (KE): A laser-focused tool for deep keyboard customization and remapping at the system level.
Feature Comparison
| Feature | BetterTouchTool | Keyboard Maestro | Karabiner-Elements |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary Focus | Input Device Customization | General Automation & Macros | Keyboard Remapping |
| Keyboard Shortcuts | ✓ (Extensive) | ✓ (Extensive, many triggers) | ✓ (Core feature) |
| Key Remapping | ✓ (Basic) | ✗ (Not primary focus) | ✓ (Advanced, low-level) |
| Trackpad Gestures | ✓ (Advanced, primary focus) | ✗ | ✗ |
| Mouse Actions | ✓ (Advanced) | ✓ (Limited) | ✗ |
| Touch Bar Support | ✓ (Extensive) | ✗ | ✗ |
| Window Management | ✓ (Built-in actions) | ✓ (Built-in actions) | ✗ |
| Text Expansion | ✓ (Simple) | ✓ (Powerful) | ✗ |
| Application Control | ✓ (Launch, quit, etc.) | ✓ (Extensive, complex workflows) | ✗ |
| Built-in Actions | ✓ (Large library) | ✓ (Vast library, community) | ✗ (Focus on remapping) |
| Scripting Support | ✓ (AppleScript, JS, Shell) | ✓ (AppleScript, JS, Shell, Swift) | ✗ (Uses JSON configuration) |
| User Interface | Complex, feature-rich | Editor focused, palettes | Simple, configuration UI |
| Community Support | ✓ (Active forum) | ✓ (Very active forum, wiki) | ✓ (GitHub issues, community) |
| Pricing Model | Paid (One-time/Subscription) | Paid (One-time per major version) | Free (Open Source) |
| Trial/Free Version | ✓ (Generous trial) | ✓ (Generous trial) | ✓ (Always free) |
Detailed App Analysis
BetterTouchTool
BetterTouchTool excels at making your input devices work exactly how you want them to.
Pros:
- Unparalleled trackpad and mouse gesture customization.
- Extensive support for various input devices (keyboard, Siri Remote, MIDI, etc.).
- Powerful Touch Bar customization.
- Built-in window management (snapping, moving, resizing).
- Clipboard manager and basic text expansion included.
- Scriptable and highly configurable.
Cons:
- The interface can be overwhelming due to the sheer number of options.
- Less focused on complex, multi-step automation workflows compared to KM.
Best For:
Users who heavily rely on trackpad gestures or want deep customization of their input devices, including window snapping and Touch Bar modifications.
Keyboard Maestro
Keyboard Maestro is the go-to for automating complex tasks and workflows.
Pros:
- Incredibly powerful and flexible macro creation.
- Wide range of triggers (hotkeys, text, application events, time, MIDI, etc.).
- Vast library of built-in actions for controlling apps, text, files, and more.
- Excellent community support and extensive documentation (Wiki, Forum).
- Robust text expansion capabilities.
- Reliable and stable.
Cons:
- Steeper learning curve for advanced features.
- Primarily focused on keyboard-driven automation; lacks BTT's input device depth.
- Interface feels a bit dated compared to modern apps.
Best For:
Power users who want to automate repetitive tasks, create complex workflows involving multiple applications, or need powerful text expansion.
Karabiner-Elements
Karabiner-Elements specializes in one thing and does it exceptionally well: keyboard remapping.
Pros:
- Deep, low-level keyboard customization.
- Excellent for remapping any key, including modifier keys (e.g., creating a "Hyper Key").
- Modify keyboard behavior based on connected devices or active applications.
- Open-source and completely free.
- Relatively simple interface for its core purpose.
Cons:
- Strictly focused on keyboard input; no automation actions, gestures, or window management.
- Configuration can involve editing JSON files for complex rules, which might deter beginners.
- Requires careful handling due to its low-level system access.
Best For:
Users whose primary goal is to remap keyboard keys, change modifier key behavior, or create custom keyboard layouts (like a Hyper Key).
Pricing Breakdown
BetterTouchTool
- License-based: Offers a standard license (valid for a specific version period) or a lifetime license.
- Generous 45-day free trial.
- Available directly from the developer's website. Also available via Setapp.
Keyboard Maestro
- License-based: One-time purchase per major version (e.g., version 11). Upgrades cost extra.
- Generous free trial with full functionality.
- Available directly from the developer's website.
Karabiner-Elements
- Completely free and open-source.
- Available directly from the developer's website.
How to Choose
- Choose BetterTouchTool if: Your main goal is customizing trackpad gestures, mouse buttons, or the Touch Bar, and you appreciate built-in window snapping.
- Go with Keyboard Maestro if: You want to automate complex workflows, manage clipboards extensively, need powerful text expansion, or trigger actions based on various system events.
- Pick Karabiner-Elements if: Your primary need is remapping keyboard keys at a fundamental level, especially modifier keys, and you prefer a free, focused tool.
Can you use them together? Absolutely! Many power users combine Karabiner-Elements (for low-level key remapping like a Hyper Key) with either BetterTouchTool or Keyboard Maestro (to assign actions to that Hyper Key combo or for other automation).
Final Verdict
There's no single "best" app; they serve different primary purposes:
- BetterTouchTool: Best for input customization.
- Keyboard Maestro: Best for workflow automation.
- Karabiner-Elements: Best for keyboard remapping.
Evaluate your main pain points and automation goals. Start with the free trial (for BTT/KM) or download Karabiner-Elements to see which tool (or combination) best fits your workflow and makes your Mac experience more efficient and personalized.
P.S. Want to get these apps at the best price? Subscribe to the apps.deals newsletter to stay updated on deals and discounts for Mac apps!
Note: Features and pricing mentioned are current as of April 2025 and may be subject to change. Always verify current offerings on the official websites.